Tag >> Branding
In an Adage article by Patrick Sarkissian, he makes the claim that metrics are indeed killing creativity. His point is really about using metrics to make creative decisions exclusively. Metrics have always been in advertising and I suspect have driven the decisions of many clients that are too afraid to take risks in general. Metrics and measurement are always important, but so is the ability to take a chance with a creative campaign that may not have all the numbers and metrics to back it up. ROI and reduced risk for business is always an important thing to consider for campaigns, but so is taking a risk. Not taking risks will get you slow and steady returns with little ,to no loss there is no question. Risks can pay off huge when the creative resonates with the audience and in the end makes for a remarkable campaign that elevates your brand or product to new levels. 
 
Measurement is essential but the human spirit quite often surprises. During the Olympics crowds of hundreds, and sometimes thousands, would spontaneously breakout into the national anthem when they were finished quite often the crowd would do it all over again. I noticed that the anthem was notably missing from most ad campaigns during the Olympics. I am not sure if it was metrics or not but if there had been an anthematic ad campaign it would have resonated without a doubt. My point is that humans are not always predictable and great creativity connects in ways that metrics cannot always predict.
 
Metrics are important sure, but should they drive all creative choices for your campaign? Sure if slow steady returns are what you are looking for. If you want the potential of a "knock it out of the park" campaign you are going to have to take some "calculated" risks to make that happen. 


Over the last few days I have noticed a sudden and strange behavior on Toyota's Twitter account. There was a huge influx of uber positive re-tweets from other Toyota fans on Twitter. There is nothing wrong with re-tweets (RT's) per say but like most tools in your toolbox understanding how and when to use them is key and from what I could see Toyota did not understand the tool at all.

toyota-tweetsThe subject matter was regarding the quality of Toyota vehicles from point of view of Toyota owners. That in its self is not an issue but the shear volume of RT's on the subject was quite large and it made more of an impression of a "See we are ok and so and so even says we are..." kind of approach. Tweets like this from @Benne420 "@Toyota as a teen driver, I still get amazing gas mileage out of my 02 Camry LE. I love my car!", from @OmarHenry "@Toyota is still the best cars around! a guy at my gym still drives a 1980's toyota with the original engine! dont believe the hype...." and from @FireCat_7 "@Toyota my first car is a 1998 Toyota Camry LE. I LOVE IT and I love Toyota. Much love guys. Keep the good work up :)" were the norm in yesterday's tweets. That is really a very guttural and unsophisticated old fashioned PR approach. Like talking really loud with your hands over your ears "LA LA LA I CAN'T HEAR YOU".

Anyone that knows me knows that I simply can't stand over use of passive self flatulence on social media sites and this was clearly one of those instances. The tactic of re-tweeting praise from other users is really no different than making the statement yourself. Who are we trying to kid here? I don't care what any social media guru tells you or your company. Be careful on that tactic because as the public become acclimatized to the vernacular of social media marketing so will they see through the thin veneer of that type prolific of re-tweeting. It's lazy social media to flood your stream with.

The tweets felt somewhat desperate and like the usual person responsible for the Twitter account had suddenly been yanked from their duties and a desperate Sr. manager with orders in hand to "DO SOMETHING' was now at the helm. The strategy veered off coarse and felt like there was a sticky accelerator on the RT button.

What should Toyota be doing? They should stay the course of the original strategy by helping the thousands of Toyota drivers out of this mess, through helpful links on how to get there cars fixed quickly, and demonstrating what the company is doing to rectify the matter and to restore confidence in the brand.

When someone is stuck at the bottom of a well that you pushed them down, get a rope and help them out. Don't stand there and tell them that everyone else you pushed was able to avoide the well all together. The whole feed in recent days is nothing but bogus PR fluff. Between the massive recalls and the congressional hearings that begin today it would be better use of social media to take this head on as apposed to head in the sand as they are continuing to do today.

Photo credit emrank


Last month I had the pleasure of sitting on a "Social Media for Business" panel discussion with Louise Clements, the Director of Sales for Facebook Canada. She shared with me some of the latest data on Canadian Facebook users that I would like to pass on. The most staggering figure that I was presented with was that "16 million Canadians spend no less than 1 hour a day on Facebook". Wow Canada has a population 33,212,696~ [stats Canada July 2008]. That's an amazing 48.48% of Canadians in total. This is why they have been working on making fan pages more useful to business and brands. With that level of Canadians engaged daily on Facebook having a fanpage for your brand is more important than ever.
 
I am just going to post the statistics and will provide some analysis later this week.
13-17 year olds
  • 54% Female
  • 46% Male
  • Each has an average of 220 friends
  • They make up 12% of the Facebook population.
  • They represent 80% of all online 12 - 17 year olds†
How are they using Facebook?
  • 77% use it more than email
  • 44% use it more than cell phones
  • 40% use it more than any other communication tool
13-17 year old Facebook behavior (in the past week):
  • 57% add/use an application
  • 41% become a fan of a page
  • 62% upload/view/share a photo
  • 39% RSVP to an event
  • 47% share/post/watch a video
  • 58% read their news feed
  • 13% send a gift [that surprised me!]
18-24 year olds
  • 48% Female
  • 52% Male
  • Each has an average of 247 friends
  • They make up 29% of the Facebook population.
  • They represent 93.8% of all online 18 - 24 year olds†
How are they using Facebook?
  • 82% use it more than email
  • 43% use it more than cell phones
  • 45% use it more than any other communication tool
18-24 year old Facebook behavior (in the past week):
  • 52% add/use an application
  • 33% become a fan of a page
  • 63% upload/view/share a photo
  • 56% RSVP to an event
  • 47%share/post/watch a video
  • 67% read their news feed
  • 20% send a gift
25-34 year olds
  • 53% Female
  • 47% Male
  • Each has an average of 153 friends
  • They make up 32% of the Facebook population.
  • They represent 27% of all online 25 - 34 year olds†
How are they using Facebook?
  • 79% use it more than email
  • 49% use it more than cell phones
  • 44% use it more than any other communication tool
25-34 year old Facebook behavior (in the past week):
  • 50% add/use an application
  • 31% become a fan of a page
  • 59% upload/view/share a photo
  • 34% RSVP to an event
  • 44% share/post/watch a video
  • 63% read their news feed
  • 19% send a gift
35-44 year olds
  • 56% Female
  • 44% Male
  • Each has an average of 85 friends
  • 67% are parents
  • They make up 16% of the Facebook population.
  • They represent 78.2% of all online 35-44 year olds†
How are they using Facebook?
  • 58% use it more than email
  • 56% use it more than cell phones
  • 47% use it more than any other communication tool
35-44 year old Facebook behavior (in the past week):
  • 62% add/use an application
  • 30% become a fan of a page
  • 60% upload/view/share a photo
  • 37% RSVP to an event
  • 43% share/post/watch a video
  • 62% read their news feed
  • 26% send a gift
45-54 year olds
  • 62% Female
  • 38% Male
  • Each has an average of 49 friends
  • 75% are parents
  • They make up 9% of the Facebook population.
  • They represent 74.8% of all online 45-54 year olds†
How are they using Facebook?
  • 65% use it more than email
  • 60% use it more than cell phones
  • 49% use it more than any other communication tool
45-54 year old Facebook behavior (in the past week):
  • 55% add/use an application
  • 28% become a fan of a page
  • 64% upload/view/share a photo
  • 29% RSVP to an event
  • 50% share/post/watch a video
  • 58% read their news feed
  • 31% send a gift
55+ year olds
  • 59% Female
  • 41% Male
  • Each has an average of 51 friends
  • 81% are parents
  • They make up 6% of the Facebook population.
  • They represent 61% of all online 55+ year olds†
How are they using Facebook?
  • 60% use it more than email
  • 69% use it more than cell phones
  • 40% use it more than any other communication tool
55+ year old Facebook behavior (in the past week):
  • 51% add/use an application
  • 25% become a fan of a page
  • 51% upload/view/share a photo
  • 30% RSVP to an event
  • 46% share/post/watch a video
  • 51% read their news feed
  • 30% send a gift
†Statistics are  from Comscore July 2009

I had the pleasure of being able to participate in Wolf Blass' 75th birthday celebration last Monday at the Hotel Vancouver. I had intended to write about it on my personal blog but after hearing Wolf speak about his early days of guerilla marketing, I realized the story belonged here instead.

II was not sure what to expect for this around-the-world birthday celebration, which was part PR for Wolf Blass Winery, and part lead-up to the launch of Blass' new book. We tasted wine and ate appetizers for nearly an hour before he and his travelling partner George Samios, from Fosters Wine Estates, hit the stage. In a thick Aussie accent, George introduced him as "Wolfy," and I quickly understood that this was a man who liked to have fun, make great wine, and knew how to sell it in every way.

Born and trained in winemaking and viticulture in what was then East Germany in 1934, Blass immigrated to Australia's Barossa Valley in 1960 with only 100 pounds in his pocket. There, he worked as a sparkling wines manager for Kaiser Stuhl Co-operative. Initially, he had wanted to go to Venezuela because of what he referred to with a wink as more "Cha, cha, cha," but there was a civil war on, so he shifted plans and wound up in Australia. I suspect that things may have been very different in the wine industry had Blass made it to his original destination. After 10 or so years as a technical advisor to many different wineries, he decided to make his own wine, and in 1973 created Wolf Blass Wines International. Wolf said the atmosphere for drinking and understanding wine in Australia was rather rudimentary-after all, this was beer country; thus, wine would have to be positioned and marketed very differently.

First, Blass identified a target group whom he could most easily persuade to drink wine. Wolf recognized that Australian women were typically not included in social drinking, and decided that "bubbly" would convince them otherwise. He then looked around at what was popular at the time, and as he put it, "Australians are mad gamblers and they love their racing and football." He noticed these popular sports featured a bold colour aesthetic on jerseys worn by the athletes. One very popular football team had a bright yellow jersey he particularly favoured, and believed yellow was a colour that the target audience would relate to. So, his now world-famous first line of wines was named Yellow Label and as he stated, "It just took off, and from then on it was going to be colours and not varietals." Inspired by Johnny Walker whiskey and its coloured label approach, Blass' colour choice for the second label in his line was adapted to green for the product's launch in Ireland. Blass' colour-coded system was easy for people to remember, as they could ask for it by Yellow Label first, and varietal second. The system has been so successful, in fact, it is now being used by the French for Cognacs and Bordeaux wines. Hell, the Scottish are even using it for the selling of fine whiskey!

When Blass started, there was very little money for advertising and he needed to think about how to maximize his limited funds. Back then, the football fields were not ringed with end-to-end billboards as they are today. When football matches were being televised, there was only one camera filming the games. Wolf would hand-paint advertisements on bed sheets, and hang them over the fence at the far end of the field. He worked out a side deal with the camera man to exchange a bottle of wine for each frame-up on the branded sheet. Quite often as the action was happening at the other end of the field, the camera would be fixed on Blass' banner, to the puzzlement of viewers. Those were the early days of guerilla marketing; Guy Kawasaki would be proud.

Wolf stated his belief that opportunities start with a conversation, and that is why his conversation is now personally taking him on a worldwide speaking tour to talk with brand loyalists and fans of Wolf Blass Wines. His discussion of the role of technology in the way people and brands are now connecting made me think of the new wine conversationalist from Wine Library TV, Gary Vaynerchuk, Although Gary doesn't make wine, he talks about it passionately and has similarly broken down barriers to entry. Through social media and modern guerilla marketing techniques, he is marketing wine in ways that resonate with real people. It's interesting to see what is old become new again.

From clear and easy to remember packaging systems, to low-fi guerilla tactics involving homemade bed sheets and cases of wine for cameramen, Wolf Blass has made a huge impact on how the world thinks about wine. Not only did he become a master vintner, but unlike so many artists, he knew how to sell it to people that didn't even know they wanted it.

Wolf Blass Mrketing and Sales Highlights
  • 1984 - 85 3.5 million bottles of Wolf Blass product sold.
  • 1985 National marketing award for excellence.
  • 1990 Exported wine to 30 different countries.
  • 2005 Wolf Blass branded products reached 50 million bottles = 70% exported.
  • 2007 16,000 containers of Wolf Blass product shipped from Port Adelaide.

I will be joined by top Vancouver social media experts Shane Gibson and Dr. Raul Pacheco-Vega for practical advice on expanding your network and increasing sales through social media marketing. The night will consist of networking, presentations and the three panelists answering questions from both the moderator and the audience.
 
Won't you join us the evening of Monday April 13th at the Harrison Gallery. Where we will answer the question. "How can you get social media working for your business?"
 
More information and tickets here>>